Natalee Holloway Part 1

Truer Crime

00:00 /

Eighteen-year-old Natalee Holloway vanished during a senior trip to Aruba, a disappearance that captured international attention and reshaped the island overnight. Her family fought for answers with a level of visibility most grieving families could only dream of. But more attention doesn’t always mean more truth.

In Part 1 of our two-part deep dive, we revisit the night Natalee went missing, the investigation that unraveled almost immediately, and the media storm that turned her case into a global spectacle. This episode examines what the spotlight illuminated, and what it obscured, in a family’s desperate search for their daughter.

Please be aware that today’s episode contains brief references to sexual assault and descriptions of violence. Please take care while listening.

“Senior portrait of Natalee Holloway in 2004.”

“Immediately after finding out that Natalee wasn’t on her flight, her parents Beth Holloway Twitty (r.) and her husband Jug Twitty (l.) flew to Aruba to assist in the search.”

“Holloway was last seen with locals Joran van der Sloot (c.) and brothers Deepak (r.) and Satish Kalpoe (l.) in a car leaving a popular nightclub. The three men would later become key suspects in Holloway’s disappearance.”

“Natalee Holloway, left, poses with friends Lee Broughton, Madison Whatley, and Ruth McVay, left to right, in a photograph taken with Natalee’s disposable camera on the beach in Aruba, May 29, 2005, hours before she disappeared.”

Natalee and her dad, Dave Holloway.

Natalee and her mom, Beth Holloway.

Missing poster created by the Holloway Family in 2005.

Action Items Related to Today’s Episode:

If you’re still here, thank you for listening. Stories like this are hard, but they matter—and there is something you can do next. We include action items at the end of every Truer Crime episode because awareness alone doesn’t bring anyone home. And it doesn’t bring justice any closer.

When Natalee Holloway went missing in Aruba in 2005, her family faced every parent’s worst nightmare. And in those first uncertain days, a volunteer search and rescue team called Texas EquuSearch (Eh-qui-search) showed up to help.

The organization was founded by Tim Miller, a father who started it after his own daughter, Laura, was kidnapped and murdered at just sixteen years old. Texas EquuSearch was born out of heartbreak, but also out of hope.

Since its early days as a small horseback search team, they’ve helped in thousands of cases across the U.S. and abroad. And they do it all at no cost to law enforcement or to the families still hoping for a miracle.

You can learn more, volunteer, or donate at TexasEquuSearch.org. Your help could fund the next search—the next chance to bring someone home.

Audio Used:

YouTube: Manhunter l 20/20 l PART 3, Uploaded by ABC News.

ABC News: Joran van der Sloot slips away to Peru, kills woman in a hotel room: Part 7.

YouTube: A Killer on the Run? Uploaded by ABC News.

YouTube: Van der Sloot’s Meeting with Flores, uploaded by CBS.

YouTube: Natalee Holloway’s Mom: FULL STATEMENT After Killer Confesses | E! News, Uploaded by E! News.

Sources Used:

People: What Happened to Natalee Holloway? Revisiting Her Case 19 Years After Her Disappearance, by Lynsey Eidell.

The Washington Post: How Natalee Holloway’s case put a spotlight on media coverage of missing White women, by Jonathan Edwards.

Biography: Natalee Holloway: A Complete Timeline of Her Disappearance in Aruba and Unsolved Case, by Tyler Piccotti, Adrienne Donica and Tim Ott.

E! News: The Whole Natalee Holloway Story May Never Be Known: Inside a Journey of Frustration and Acceptance, by Natalie Finn.